[email protected]+44 7427 252575العربية
KADHIMS

London Civil Fraud Conference 2026: Key Developments in Freezing Injunctions and Contempt

Recent Developments in Civil Fraud: Freezing Orders, Jurisdiction, and the Shifting Approach to Costs

The landscape of civil fraud litigation continues to evolve, with the courts currently exhibiting a more exacting approach towards jurisdictional gateways and applications for contempt, contrasted by a growing flexibility regarding interim costs. Drawing on discussions from the November 2026 London Civil Fraud Conference, hosted by Essex Court Chambers, this update synthesises the key takeaways for commercial practitioners navigating the complexities of freezing orders and their associated enforcement mechanics.

The Merits Threshold: A Stable Baseline

Despite recent debate, the courts have maintained a stable approach to the merits requirements for freezing injunctions, resisting calls to increase the evidentiary burden on applicants. The baseline standard remains that of demonstrating a “good arguable case”. Addressing this point directly in Isabel dos Santos v Unitel SA [2024] EWCA Civ 1109, Popplewell LJ observed that, even were the courts to elevate the merits test, such a shift would rarely alter the practical outcome of an application for a freezing order.

Corporate Structures and Asset Reach

When seeking to extend freezing orders beyond a defendant’s personal assets to third-party entities, practitioners must rely on specific and carefully pleaded legal frameworks. As Foxton J clarified in his October 2024 lecture, “The Big Freeze”: The Rise and Rise of the Mareva Injunction, a standard freezing order does not automatically capture companies owned by the respondent. To police external assets effectively, the Chabra jurisdiction must be expressly engaged.

There are, however, notable exceptions where the courts will extend their reach. Where a defendant exercises direct control over assets, those assets may be captured. This extends to discretionary trust assets, famously illustrated by the 2015 Pugachev litigation (JSC Mezhdunarodniy Promyshlenniy Bank v Pugachev [2017] EWHC 2426 (Ch)), or to assets held by a trustee company, as demonstrated by the tracing of the Maserati in the Australian decision of Filippini v Keystone Asset Management Limited [2024] FCAFC 71.

Jurisdictional Gateways: A Stricter Approach

It is a fundamental principle that the court’s general power to issue a freezing injunction is entirely distinct from its ability to establish personal jurisdiction over a foreign respondent. The Privy Council’s decision in Convoy Collateral Ltd v Broad Idea International Ltd [2021] UKPC 24 firmly reinforced the position that even a substantively justified freezing order will fail against a foreign respondent absent a valid statutory gateway for service out of the jurisdiction.

Claimants frequently attempt to rely on Gateway 20 (the enactment gateway) for freezing orders. However, section 37 of the Senior Courts Act 1981 (SCA) confers only a general remedial power, rather than a specific statutory claim. Gateway 20 nonetheless remains highly effective for specific statutory claims commonly deployed in international fraud, such as those under section 423 of the Insolvency Act 1986, or third-party disclosure applications under section 34 of the SCA (as confirmed in Gorbachev v Guriev ([2024] EWHC 2174 (Comm)).

These severe jurisdictional hurdles in serving Chabra respondents abroad were recently affirmed by the Court of Appeal in Gilbert v Broadoak [2026] EWCA Civ 1172, a decision which exposes a critical lacuna in the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) regarding domestic judgments. The Court upheld the discharge of a worldwide freezing order against Spanish respondents, confirming that section 37 of the SCA is not a “claim conferring enactment” for the purposes of the Enactment Gateway. Furthermore, consistent with Siskina v Distos Cia Naviera SA ([1979] AC 210), the Injunction Gateway applies strictly to final remedies, rather than interim freezing orders. The Property Gateway similarly failed because the subject matter of an injunction is not “wholly or principally” property within the jurisdiction.

A stark anomaly emerges from this: while the CPR provides a gateway to serve a freezing order application abroad to assist in enforcing a foreign judgment, no equivalent provision exists to assist the enforcement of domestic judgments. For claimants seeking Chabra relief against foreign respondents, the strategic position is clear. They must now pivot towards alternative routes, such as the “necessary or proper party” gateway, or ensure they bring substantive claims that fall within recognised gateways, such as claims under section 423 of the Insolvency Act or those seeking constructive trust relief.

Policing Contempt in Commercial Litigation

A marked rise in hostility within commercial dispute resolution has triggered an influx of contempt applications. In response, the courts have shown a willingness to firmly manage procedural boundaries. In Navigator Equities Limited v Deripaska, Andrew Baker J (both in 2020 and more recently in 2024) struck down a contempt application, ruling it was inappropriately driven by personal animosity rather than the public interest.

However, the legal framework distinguishing civil and criminal contempt requires careful navigation. While criminal contempt requires applicants to act dispassionately as guardians of the public interest (as established in KJM Superbikes Ltd v Hinton [2008] EWCA Civ 1280), the Court of Appeal in Navigator Equities ultimately ruled that an applicant’s subjective motivation is legally irrelevant for civil contempt. Moving forward, there are indications of a potential judicial shift towards applying a more uniform “suitability requirement” across all contempt applications, a development practitioners should monitor closely.

The Shifting Approach to Interim Costs

Historically, the default practice was to reserve the costs of freezing injunction applications for the trial judge. This is rapidly shifting in favour of immediate costs evaluations. Following the Dos Santos ruling in 2024, the courts are increasingly willing to award costs immediately to an applicant who succeeds at a contested interim hearing, thereby treating interim success as entirely distinct from the eventual outcome at trial.

These costs evaluations remain strictly tethered to a party’s conduct during the application process. Recently, for example, a claimant who failed to disclose crucial information at an ex parte hearing suffered an immediate adverse costs order, despite ultimately succeeding at trial. For the recovery of costs, practitioners must now strictly compartmentalise the costs of the without-notice application, the return date hearing, and any subsequent discharge applications; the courts may determine that each distinct phase warrants a wholly different costs order.

Ultimately, these developments serve as a timely reminder. Whether navigating the merits of a freezing application, establishing jurisdictional gateways, or pursuing contempt proceedings, the courts increasingly demand absolute procedural rigour from commercial practitioners.

Contact Kadhims for more information or advice if you need help on freezing injunctions.

Cover photo (courtesy) Joshua Earle